2009-10 Honor Roll
The following athletes were honored by the NJCAA, Region III, or the Western New York Athletic Conference.
2009-10 Athletic Honor Roll
Previous Year: 2008-09, 2007-08, 2006-07
NJCAA All-American
| Carey Crooker | Cross Country |
| Carey Crooker | Outdoor Track & Field (2 Events) |
| Brandon Lewis | Cross Country |
| Bridget McMahon | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Pamela Breedlove | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Joe Seitz | Cross Country |
| John Sweeney | Cross Country |
| John Sweeney | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Kelsey Wissert | Outdoor Track & Field |
All-Region
| Ashley Andrus | Swimming |
| Chase Bailey | Lacrosse |
| Kyle Barkley | Baseball |
| Abbey Benton | Cross Country |
| Pamela Breedlove | Indoor Track & Field (2 Events) |
| Brittney Brooks | Basketball |
| Mark Ciccotti | Baseball |
| Carey Crooker | Outdoor Track & Field (2 Events) |
| Jake Dale | Baseball |
| Michael Fingar | Lacrosse |
| Pete Francia | Indoor Track & Field |
| JP Frey | Baseball |
| Brittany Haines | Volleyball |
| Brandon Lewis | Cross Country |
| Bridget McMahon | Indoor Track & Field |
| Bridget McMahon | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Shawna McNeil | Basketball |
| TJ Nelson | Wrestling |
| Mo Parks | Soccer |
| Cory Roberts | Swimming |
| Eric Shedden | Wrestling |
| Eddie Sparks | Indoor Track & Field |
| Eddie Sparks | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Ryan Speciale | Lacrosse |
| John Sweeney | Cross Country |
| John Sweeney | Indoor Track & Field |
| John Sweeney | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Joe Wallace | Baseball |
| Yakima Williams | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Neil Wilson | Basketball |
| Shelby Winchester | Soccer |
| Kelsey Wissert | Outdoor Track & Field |
| Brian Zimmermann | Baseball |
All-WNYAC
| Kevin Arilotta | Soccer |
| Chase Bailey | Lacrosse |
| Kyle Barkley | Baseball |
| Brittney Brooks | Basketball |
| Mark Ciccotti | Baseball |
| Jake Dale | Baseball |
| Angie Depew | Softball |
| Brian Ervay | Baseball |
| JP Frey | Baseball |
| Brittany Haines | Volleyball |
| Steven Hickey | Soccer |
| Therese Hubbel | Soccer |
| Dan Krajcir | Soccer |
| Jackie Matteson | Soccer |
| Shawna McNeil | Basketball |
| James Moss | Lacrosse |
| Charise Nankivell | Softball |
| TJ Nelson | Wrestling |
| Mo Parks | Soccer |
| Rasean Parris | Basketball |
| Audrey Rath | Soccer |
| Erik Reynolds | Soccer |
| Eric Shedden | Wrestling |
| Jessie Smith | Soccer |
| Steve Smith | Baseball |
| Ryan Speciale | Lacrosse |
| Neil Wilson | Basketball |
| Shelby Winchester | Soccer |
| Masanari Yamamoto | Soccer |
| Nick Young | Lacrosse |
| Brian Zimmermann | Baseball |