2012-13 Honor Roll
The following athletes were honored by the NJCAA, Region III, or the Western New York Athletic Conference.
Previous Years: 2011-12, 2010-11, 2009-10, 2008-09, 2007-08, 2006-07
NJCAA All-American
| Nate Andres | Outdoor Track |
| Billie Carroll (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Desmond Chambers | Outdoor Track |
| Brian Edwards | Outdoor Track |
| Ismail El-Amin (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Hannah Holmok | Soccer |
| Robert Howard | Outdoor Track |
| Nicole Lipa | Outdoor Track |
| Kali Muhleisen | Soccer |
| Travis Nagle | Outdoor Track |
| Jedadiah Platt | Cross Country |
| Jordan Rusek | Cross Country |
| Brian Tubbs (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Zach Woodward (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
All-Region
| Tyler Aldinger | Wrestling |
| Nate Andres (x2) | Indoor Track |
| Nate Andres (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Dileel Bartley | Football |
| Frankie Bailey | Indoor Track |
| Frankie Bailey | Outdoor Track |
| Lera Braun | Volleyball |
| Colton Caldwell | Football |
| Anthony Carome | Wrestling |
| Billie Carroll (x 3) | Outdoor Track |
| Desmond Chambers (x2) | Indoor Track |
| Desmond Chambers (x 3) | Outdoor Track |
| Thomas Daniels | Football |
| Jen DeNovio | Outdoor Track |
| Sammy Diaz | Football |
| Megan Dillon | Indoor Track |
| Ella Donovan | Indoor Track |
| Ismail El-Amin (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Brian Edwards | Indoor Track |
| Brian Edwards (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Karley Fanning | Basketball |
| Alex Farrell | Outdoor Track |
| Conner Fox | Wrestling |
| Collin Frazer | Football |
| Michael Gibson | Football |
| Zachary Hale | Outdoor Track |
| Travis Harvey | Wrestling |
| Claire Holleran | Cross Country |
| Hannah Holmok | Soccer |
| Caitlyn Hotchkiss | Indoor Track |
| Robert Howard (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| David Howell | Football |
| Kyle Jones | Outdoor Track |
| Jayvon Larkin | Indoor Track |
| Tylor Lehman | Outdoor Track |
| Nicole Lipa | Indoor Track |
| Nicole Lipa | Outdoor Track |
| Ethan Livernash | Wrestling |
| Kim Lupo | Cross Country |
| Cody Marvin | Indoor Track |
| Katy Monahan | Cross Country |
| Aubri Mosier | Softball |
| Kali Muhleisen | Soccer |
| Kelsey Murray | Soccer |
| Travis Nagle (x 2) | Indoor Track |
| Travis Nagle (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Dan Ognibene | Wrestling |
| Mark Pendleton | Swimming |
| Kay Pfleghardt | Volleyball |
| Logan Phillips | Indoor Track |
| Logan Phillips | Outdoor Track |
| Jedadiah Platt | Cross Country |
| Rafael Ramirez | Outdoor Track |
| Jordan Rusek | Cross Country |
| Jen Sanders | Indoor Track |
| Sam Sherwin | Outdoor Track |
| Erik Simmons | Football |
| Anthony Soto | Outdoor Track |
| Tiara Summers (x 3) | Indoor Track |
| Josiah Thomas | Indoor Track |
| Josiah Thomas (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
| Brian Tubbs (x 3) | Outdoor Track |
| Maura Tuffey | Soccer |
| Jamar White | Basketball |
| Haley Witchella | Basketball |
| Haley Witchella | Indoor Track |
| Zach Woodard (x 2) | Outdoor Track |
All-WNYAC
| Michael Alessi | Lacrosse |
| Lera Braun | Volleyball |
| Krista DeCarlo | Soccer |
| Karley Fanning | Basketball |
| Conner Fox | Wrestling |
| Brandon Griffin | Lacrosse |
| Hannah Holmok | Soccer |
| Daiki Iizuka | Baseball |
| Kyle Jones | Soccer |
| Aubri Mosier | Softball |
| Kali Muhleisen | Soccer |
| Brad Murdoch | Lacrosse |
| Kelsey Murray | Soccer |
| Nick Peraino | Soccer |
| Kay Pfleghardt | Volleyball |
| Keegan Phalen | Lacrosse |
| Mitchell Porter | Soccer |
| Jessica Ramsey | Volleyball |
| Brett Rapan | Baseball |
| Stephen Solomon | Baseball |
| Kelly Stieve | Soccer |
| Maura Tuffey | Soccer |
| Ally Vargeson | Soccer |
| Jordan Wheaton | Baseball |
| Jamar White | Basketball |
| Haley Witchella | Basketball |